A Colorado judge has ordered a couple to pay more than $950 million for allegedly giving grieving families urns full of fake ashes and running a bug-infested funeral home facility where 190 improperly stored bodies were found in various states of decay.
The judgment was issued in a civil class-action lawsuit against Jon and Carie Hallford, who owned the Return to Nature Funeral Home in Penrose, Colorado. It is the first high-profile case against the couple to return a ruling.
The bodies and the extent of the couple’s alleged fraud were discovered late last year after area residents reported a putrid stench emanating from the Penrose facility. The discovery sparked a massive investigation that came to include local, state, and federal investigators and responders. The FBI deployed a team of agents trained to respond to mass casualty events, such as airline crashes.
In addition to the class-action suit, the Hallfords face hundreds of state and federal criminal charges over their allegedly fraudulent funeral services. Specifically, the couple faces 286 charges at the state level, including felony charges of abuse of a corpse, theft, money laundering, and forgery, according to the Colorado Springs Gazette.
At the federal level, they face 13 counts of wire fraud and two additional counts of conspiracy to commit wire fraud. The US Department of Justice alleges that the pair defrauded grieving customers by not providing the cremation and burial services for the deceased as promised, despite collecting more than $130,000 in payments.
“Frustrating”
Further, federal prosecutors also accuse the couple of lying to the US Small Business Administration to obtain nearly $900,000 in COVID relief funds. The false information provided included “misrepresenting the fact that Jon Hallford owed back child support,” the DOJ noted. And the couple allegedly used the ill-gotten business funds to pay for vacations, cosmetic surgery, and jewelry, among other personal expenses, according to unsealed court documents. If convicted on the federal counts, they could both face around seven years in prison.
Last month, the Gazette reported that state authorities offered the Hallfords a plea deal, in which they would plead guilty to 190 counts of abuse of a corpse, Jon would then serve a mandatory sentence of 20 years in prison, and Carie would serve between 15 and 20 years. Affected family members were reportedly upset by the offer, saying they were not informed of the proposed deal ahead of time and did not feel it reflected the egregiousness of the alleged crimes. It’s unclear if the Hallfords have or will take the deal.
As for the nearly $1 billion payout in the class-action case, the judgment is largely symbolic with the expectation that the Hallfords do not have such money.
“I’m never going to get a dime from them, so, I don’t know, it’s a little frustrating,” Crystina Page told the Associated Press. Page paid the Hallfords to cremate her son’s remains in 2019 and received an urn they claimed held his ashes. She carried the urn around the country until his body was discovered in the Penrose location amid the investigation late last year.
On top of the financial disappointment, affected families did not get the opportunity to face the Hallfords in court as they had hoped. Both Hallfords refused to cooperate with the case or show up for hearings.
Jon Hallford is currently in custody pending the outcome of his federal case. Carie Hallford is out on a $100,000 bond.
